FAFEN Survey of DHQs, THQs Lack of doctors, dissatisfied patients warrant prompt govt interventions

MULTAN, July 12, 2010: Tehsil and District Headquarters Hospitals are the backbone of state-run healthcare infrastructure, but the lack of doctors and nurses, patients’ dissatisfaction about the services and attitude of hospital staff, and poor infrastructure and sanitation at some hospitals warrant prompt government interventions to put this public sector healthcare system back on track, reports FAFEN’s Health Institution Monitor for the month of July 2010, released here Monday.

FAFEN’s Governance Monitors visited 107 hospitals (61 DHQs and 46 THQs) in 81 districts and two FATA agencies across Pakistan during June 2010. Monitored facilities included44 hospitals in 31 districts of Punjab (19 THQs and 25 DHQs), 23 hospitals in 20 districts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (9 THQs and 14 DHQs), 8hospitals in similar number of districtsof Balochistan (seven DHQs and one THQ), 30 hospitals in 21 districts of Sindh (14 DHQs and 16 THQs) and two hospitals in two FATA Agencies (one DHQ and THQ each).

While 96% of sanctioned doctors’ posts at District Headquarters Hospitals (DHQs), observed by FAFEN Monitors in the month of June 2010 are filled, the occupancy rate of doctors against sanctioned posts in Tehsil Headquarters Hospitals (THQs) is only 55% nationally. The lowest occupancy rates are in Balochistan and Sindh, where 60% and 59% of doctors’ posts are vacant, respectively. About 57% of posts for female doctors at THQs are vacant across the country. Almost half of THQ nurses’ posts are unfilled nationwide (49%), including about 80% of sanctioned nurses’ posts in Sindh.

More than one-fourth of the patients (27%) interviewed around the country at observed hospitals said that they were not happy with the way doctors had treated them at DHQs and THQs, and the same percentage expressed frustration about the absence of doctors at DHQs. About 21% of thepatients interviewed by FAFEN Monitors at THQs of Punjab and 33% each in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Sindh also complained that doctors were not present.

The buildings of about 12% of the nationwideobserved hospitals are in a dilapidated condition including about 21% of monitored DHQs in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Sanitation and hygienic conditions also warrant prompt governmental attention, especially in Balochistan (where 38% have sanitation problems) and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (17%). In addition, almost 13% of visited hospitals in Balochistan and 4% in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa do not have any electricity connection whatsoever, crippling the hospitals’ ability to offer basic services required by such a public facility.


FAFEN is a network of 35 civil society organizations working to foster democratic accountabilities in Pakistan. It is governed by Trust for Democratic Education and Accountability. For more information please visit www.fafen.org