Balochistan Assembly: 38% Lawmakers Stay Mum during Budget Debate

  • Balochistan Lawmakers Contribution to Budget Debate Remains High as Compared to Other Assemblies
  • All Female Lawmakers Take Part in Budget Debate

ISLAMABAD, June 22, 2017: The Balochistan Assembly passed the Finance Bill 2017 during its 42nd session following debates by nearly 62 percent of the lawmakers, observes Free and Fair Election Network (FAFEN) in its Session Report.

Forty lawmakers (62%) contributed in the Budget Debate in the Provincial Assembly of Balochistan while 25 members (38%) did not participate in the general discussion on budget. No lawmaker moved any cut motion – a tool to express disapproval or dissatisfaction over budgetary proposals.

All 25 non-participating members were male of which twelve belonged to PML-N followed by NP (four), PkMAP, BNP and PML (two each), JUI-F, BNP-A (one each) and an Independent lawmaker.

Meanwhile, twenty-nine male and all eleven female lawmakers participated in budget debate and expressed their views for eight hours and thirty-four minutes. Twelve participating members were from PkMAP followed by PML-N (nine), NP and JUI-F (seven each), PML (three), ANP and MWM (one each).

During the budget sessions of Provincial Assemblies, 60% of the lawmakers contributed to the budget debate in the Sindh Assembly, 37% legislators in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Assembly and 21% in Punjab Assembly.

Provincial Minister for Finance presented the Provincial Budget for the Financial Year 2017-18 during first sitting on June 15, 2017 following which the House initiated general discussion on it. The Opposition Leader opened budget debate during second sitting and spoke for 30 minutes while the Chief Minster concluded debate on budget in his 32 minutes speech during fifth sitting.

The House passed the Balochistan Finance Bill, 2017 and approved a total of 77 Demand for Grants including 58 Demands for Grants for Year 2017-18 and 19 Supplementary Demand for Grants for Year 2016-17.  No member from the Opposition parties moved any Cut Motion pertaining to Demands for Grants of various government departments. The Finance Minister also laid two budget documents – the Schedule of Authorized Expenditure 2017-18 and the Supplementary Schedule of Authorized Expenditure 2016-17 – before the House during last (6th) sitting on June 22, 2017.

The Budget session comprising six sittings, commenced on June 15 and prorogued on June 22, 2017. Twelve hours and fifteen minutes long session starting with an average delay of 35 minutes per sitting was attended by maximum 45 members. On average, 29 members were observed to be present at start and 37 at the end of each sitting.

The Speaker and Leader of the House attended all six sittings while the Leader of the Opposition was present in five sittings.  The Speaker presided over the entire session time (12 hours and 15 minutes). The Chief Minister and Minister for Finance remained present during entire proceeding’s time while the Leader of the Opposition attended 99 percent of the session.

The Parliamentary Leaders of PML and PkMAP attended all sitting of the session followed by ANP (5), NP (4) and MWM (3). The Parliamentary Leader of BNP did not attend any of the sitting.

During the second sitting, NP lawmakers walked out of the House for eight minutes after exchange of heated arguments with PkMAP members on an issue of budgetary allocation. JUI-F and ANP lawmakers walked out of the House during third sitting for ten minutes against the attitude of Chief Minister with Opposition members.

Additionally, lawmakers raised eight Points of Order consuming fifteen minutes of the total session time.

To download complete report, click here